Nuby IcyBite Teething Keys
Nuby IcyBite Teething Keys
Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you — it never changes our scores or which toys we include.
Safety Score
87/100Development Score
70/100Materials
- Manufacturer-reported BPA-free plastic.
- purICE gel
- food-grade materials
Material descriptions are as reported by the manufacturer or retailer. SafeNest has not independently verified them.
Choking Hazard Research
Keys are large and connected to ring. Ring handle is too large to swallow. Gel is sealed and manufacturer-reported non-toxic. The manufacturer labels this product for ages 3 months and older.
Wording reflects publicly available product information. SafeNest has not physically measured or tested this product. Follow the current packaging, warnings and supervision guidance.
Certifications
Manufacturer-reported. Not independently verified by SafeNest.
What we liked, and what we didn't
SafeNest's editorial opinion, based on publicly available product information. These are preferences and observations, not verified safety findings.
Pros
- Cooling gel soothes teething pain
- Multiple textures for gum massage
- Very affordable
- Easy to grip ring handle
Cons
- Must refrigerate for cooling effect
- Gel can become warm quickly
- Limited play value beyond teething
Alternatives
SafeNest editorial safety assessment: 87/100 — Medium evidence confidence.
The important claims are mostly manufacturer-reported and have not been independently verified.
SafeNest scores are editorial research tools based on publicly available information. Evidence confidence describes how well that information is supported. Neither is a certification, guarantee, endorsement or substitute for manufacturer instructions and official recall notices. Read the full methodology.
Evidence for each safety factor
- Material safety(30% of score)Manufacturer-reported
What the toy is made of, based on published materials information and warnings.
Not supported by documentation SafeNest could access, so this factor lowers the evidence confidence above.
- Choking risk(30% of score)Manufacturer-reported
Assessed from published dimensions, construction details, small-part warnings, and the manufacturer's age guidance. SafeNest does not perform physical small-parts testing.
Not supported by documentation SafeNest could access, so this factor lowers the evidence confidence above.
- Recall history(20% of score)Official government source
Based on checks against publicly available CPSC recall information, as of the recorded check date.
Is the Nuby IcyBite Teething Keys right for your child?
- Best for
- Cooling gel soothes teething pain
- Not ideal for
- Must refrigerate for cooling effect
- Manufacturer age guidance
- 3–18 months. Age suitability is the manufacturer's labelling, not a SafeNest determination.
- Main limitation
- Gel can become warm quickly
- Evidence confidence
- Medium alongside an editorial assessment of 87/100. A high editorial score with Low or Medium evidence confidence should be interpreted cautiously.
- Merchant options
- Amazon is the only merchant SafeNest links for this product. Check the merchant for current price and availability.
Some links here are affiliate links. If you buy through one we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you — it never changes our scores or which toys we include.